Brilliant IPO success stories such as those of Yahoo! and Amazon.com are
widely known. The reality for many IPOs is quite different. Studies by E&Y
and data from Securities Data Company reveal a more realistic picture.
-
Most IPOs perform
poorly in the first three years after going public - significantly
underperforming the overall market in both operating and share price
returns.
-
Those that succeed
view the IPO as a transformation process, while the unsuccessful
companies treat it as an event or short-term financial
transaction.
-
In retrospect, 62%
of the executives in unsuccessful companies considered themselves
ill prepared for their IPO.
Why do so many IPOs wind
up with these results? One reason is that companies going public through
IPOs face two challenging and concurrent transformations. First, the
business evolution required to add profitable growth, positive cash flow,
and shareholder value to their technology and product focus, and second,
a cultural transformation from a private company or internal division of a
large company to a stand-alone public Company.
IPO
executive teams face four critical challenges: 1) building and maintaining
investor confidence to attract capital, 2) maintaining Company value through
the IPO process and beyond, and 3) preparing the organization and employees
to manage a public Company that meets the profitable growth, return on
investment, and cash flow expectations of shareholders, and 4) executing the
transition to a financially focused public company.
Building
and Maintaining Investor Confidence
Attracting
investment capital requires the new Company executives to demonstrate that
they understand the investors’ financial return and risk requirements, and
be able to convince prospective investors that the new Company will satisfy
those requirements.
They must
demonstrate how the new Company will be competitive, profitable, and
generate shareholder value in the short- and long-term. In addition, quick
and confident responses to questions or concerns raised by securities
analysts, investors, and lenders in financial terms must become second
nature to them.
Realistic
plans are required to manage the critical transformation from a parent
corporate culture to an entrepreneurial culture. Executives need
to prove that their business model, strategy and operating plans will
provide outstanding customer value, sustainable competitive advantages in
technology, products, innovation capability, and a highly skilled and
engaged workforce. Stringent regulatory requirements such as Sarbanes-Oxley
must also be met.
At this
juncture, CFOs play a vital role as presenter and as supporter of other
executive presentations and Q&A sessions with securities analysts,
investors, and lenders.
Maintaining Company Value during the IPO Process and Beyond
Extraordinary cooperation on multiple levels can make or break the
transformation. Dealing effectively with transition requires all executives
to demonstrate the leadership necessary to quickly design and implement the
critical change initiatives.
Paramount
to the process is continuous communication with all stakeholder groups.
Doing so assures that everyone’s interests are carefully considered before
and after the IPO and that commitments made are honored. This is achieved
by Company executives and operating managers meeting frequently with major
customers, suppliers, investors, and lenders to maintain existing and
ongoing relationships.
Continuous, open and comprehensive communication with employees is also a
vital part of maintaining business focus. Frequent CEO, CFO, and senior
operating managers updates for employee with personal visits to sites and
through the company newsletter can achieve this. Business unit finance
managers can lead on-going information sessions for employees where the
financial reasons and benefits of the required changes in operating
strategies and organization are discussed.
Quick
Preparation of the Organization and Employees to Manage After the IPO
Management
performance guidelines and rewards shift from those dictated by the parent
to the new Company’s goals, strategies, and business model. At this
juncture performance in many newly public companies changes to being judged
by profitable growth and cash to a much larger degree. It’s essential to
implement performance measures that encourage managers to focus on financial
results, along with technology and product results.
Without the parent
company ’bank’ to fund investments, the new company must generate or raise
its own capital funds, requiring a laser focus on cash flow. Quite simply,
cash flow becomes a major factor in all investment decisions.
Once established, it is
vital for the new Vision, Values, Mission, short- and long-term goals and
strategies be communicated in clear and unambiguous terms companywide.
Aligning managers and employees with the new goals and strategies speeds the
shift to a financially focused public company.
At all levels, managers
and employees must have a working knowledge of business finance terms and
concepts to better understand the company’s financial goals, how it makes
money, why the organizational changes are being made, and what is expected
of them going forward. Sound financial knowledge is needed to quickly
design and implement the critical change initiatives to transform the new
company into a profitable public company. Business unit finance managers
can use this time to build their working relations with operating managers,
many of whom need financial counsel.
For these reasons,
managers at all levels must become shareholder value leaders, able and
willing to help people in their organizations manage for profitable growth
and positive cash flow in an ever-changing market place.
Meeting the Challenges
For
businesses being spun off from large corporations, incumbent division
managers are often appointed executives and senior managers of the newly
formed pubic Company. While they fully understand the products and
technology of the business, they have little understanding of corporate
finance, since corporate groups normally handle investor relations,
financing, and cash management.
Not only
do they face a wide range of issues never dealt with before - stock exchange
and government rules and regulations and oversight [previously the purview
of the corporation] – but also they find that the ‘corporate bank’ is no
longer available to them. The new Company must generate or raise its own
operating and investment capital.
Managers who have not
had return on investment and cash flow responsibility previously may be
reluctant to take responsibility for financial performance if they are
unclear about what their new roles entail and what is expected of them.
Financial
Management Development Strategy
There are
a number of ways to satisfy four collective objectives: building investor
confidence, maintaining the value of the Company during the IPO process,
preparing the new Company for speedy profitability to meet shareholder
expectations, and successfully
executing the transition to a financially focused public company.
While senior management can elect to deal with each of the challenges
individually, some companies take another approach. They start by providing
executives and managers with the foundation upon which meeting all the
objectives stand - strategic financial knowledge, information, and
tools. Their plans are based on bringing all executives and managers
into customized management development workshops starting immediately;
followed by employee participation on a second tier.
Not only
does this prepare the managers for the IPO and successful operation as a
public company, but it also shows prospective investors that the company is
serious about increasing managers’ financial knowledge, skills, and
commitment to financial results improvement.
Strategic
Financial Workshops
Before
launching the workshop program business unit executives and operating
managers should be interviewed to determine their comprehension of the new
Company vision, values, mission, goals, and strategies, and to determine how
well they understand the Company’s new business model and financial
performance measures. Even at the executive level there are often wide
differences in knowledge and commitment.
“Our
workshops provided practical examples and exercises that focused on
identifying what factors determine shareholder value,” the CFO of a newly
public company said. “It was critical that our management discover the
significance of the shareholder value. They needed to learn the most
beneficial approach to interact with investors, analysts and everyone
involved.”
Workshops
in several companies studied focused on six key challenges that Company
executives and managers would face: 1) the business would receive more
scrutiny from analysts, investors, and lenders than it did as an operating
division or private company, 2) changes would be required in strategies,
organization, and performance measures, 3) cash would become a significant
factor in the Company’s success, 4) all managers would have two jobs – to
build successful products and create shareholder value, 5) new ways to
communicate the strategic and financial reasons for all changes to all
employees would be essential, and 6) transformation of the organization to
an entrepreneurial culture would be imperative.
Executive
workshops
examine key
factors that drive valuation of the Company during the separation and
beyond. Financial valuation models can be used to illustrate how changes in
income and expense impact the valuation of the Company and its share price.
Senior managers must understand how their decisions directly affect
shareholder value, and how to evaluate decisions about buying and selling
businesses, long-term investments, financing, cash-flow planning, make vs.
buy decisions, the effects of different strategies, and performance
improvement measures.
Specialists should be
engaged to inform senior managers about areas requiring detailed
understanding and analysis including government regulations, tax issues,
currency issues, stock exchange rules and regulations, and financing options
and tradeoffs.
Operating
Management workshops
provide managers opportunities to discuss with other managers vital issues
facing the business units, including:
-
Definition of shareholder value, how it’s created, and how creating
shareholder value creates value for all stakeholders (customers,
shareholders, suppliers, lenders, and employees).
-
The
latest financial results of the Company and projected results compared
with competitors’ results to identify Company successes, shortcomings,
and needs for improvement.
-
How
the Company vision, mission, goals and strategies are linked to revenue,
profit, and cash flow goals and performance measures.
-
Trends
in internal operations financial performance metrics as the basis for
evaluating the operating effectiveness and efficiencies of the Company
and its competitors.
-
Factors that drive revenue, costs, profit, assets and cash flow, and
ways to maximize them.
-
Actions that each manager can take to generate profitable growth and
positive cash flow.
-
The
five crucial questions used to make business decisions
-
Approaches for working as business partners with finance managers in all
phases of creating economic value.
Workshop participants
profit improvement recommendations can be collected in every workshop and
given to management for evaluation, selection, and funding. Planned results
of chosen ideas can be added to individual and organization performance
measures. Successful goal achievements should be publicly recognized and
rewarded.
The most
effective implementations are often a top-down process with the information
cascading throughout the organization from the executive team then filtering
to middle management and to all employees.
Results of the
Financial Management Development Strategy
Companies that have employed the strategic financial management development
strategy report several results that include: 1) executives successfully
responded to potential investors’ and lenders’ requirements, concerns, and
questions, 2) the two major transformations proceeded according to plan, 3)
managers demonstrated substantial increases in financial knowledge, 4)
executives and managers learned to speak the language of business finance
within the Company, and with investors, customers, and suppliers, and
5) the new Company’s business vision, mission, goals and strategies, market
challenges and opportunities, internal Company challenges and opportunities,
financing needs, and requirements for positive cash flow were documented and
communicated to managers and employees throughout the company.
Conclusion
Strategic
financial management development - when incorporated with other initiatives
– can be a powerful force for change and profitable growth in business.
Author: Penn Post
PENN
POST designs and conducts seminars that promote positive change within
organizations. Incorporating proven tactics with unmatched success for 25
years, Mr. Post’s seminars include: Managing for Financial Success &
Shareholder Value; Shareholder Value Leadership; Business Planning and
Analysis; Growing Revenue; Profit and Cash Flow Management; and Sales
Training.
e-mail:
penn@postassoc.com · Telephone: (949) 706-0623
Mr. Post
authored Ten Ways to Improve Profitability, and is a Certified
Management Consultant (CMC). |